MAYVILLE, NY — Six months after calling on state and federal law enforcement to investigate persistently higher gasoline prices in Chautauqua County, County Executive Paul M. Wendel Jr. says he remains committed to finding answers and advocating for residents.
Despite having a lower sales tax on gasoline than neighboring Erie County, Chautauqua County residents continue to pay more at the pump than those in surrounding regions. County Executive Wendel has repeatedly reached out to New York State Attorney General Letitia James and to both current and former U.S. Attorneys for the Western District of New York, requesting a review of motor fuel pricing in the County.
While the Attorney General’s Office has indicated that, in their view, no illegal activity is occurring and will not pursue an investigation, the County has yet to receive a response from the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
“Chautauqua County families, small businesses, and commuters are paying more at the pump than their neighbors,” Wendel said. “I pump gas just like everyone else, and this is an issue that continues to impact the cost of living in our community. We are not giving up.”
While efforts continue to seek better answers, County Executive Wendel encourages residents to compare prices, seek the lowest-cost stations, and use tools like GasBuddy (www.gasbuddy.com). Making informed choices helps create competitive pressure that can encourage lower prices throughout the region.
County Executive Wendel first raised concerns in June 2025, citing AAA data showing Chautauqua County’s gasoline prices significantly above the state and national averages. His office continues to monitor trends and will keep residents updated on any developments.
